Appropriate Feedback with Forms

Once a user has submitted text or an answer to a question or multiple choice items it is important that correct feedback is received to prevent confusion. There should be no time restrictions and clear methods for pausing items or returning to a page to correct an error. (W3C WCAG 2.0 2.2, W3C WCAG 2.0 2.4 and W3C WCAG 2.0 3.3)

Testing Techniques

These techniques may be used to perform the test.

Method

Manual assessment. Please comment on whether the screen reader can reach the feedback window, even if you can see it. Check using NVDA or Thunder with WebbIE. It may be a pop up window which may not be accessible.

Criteria for this Test

Poor No feedback, user may be confused about what to do next and times-out. May offer audio feedback only.
Fair User directed between steps in a process, no information about the process but time limiters shown.
Good Some text feedback (e.g. "bad username"), or new page reached without further action, time allowance if offered can be extended.
Excellent Appropriate feedback, user directed to what they should do next, no time restrictions.

Results for this Test

Score Product
Excellent30Boxes
ExcellentAmazon
ExcellentAnimoto
ExcellentAnobii
ExcellentAnswers.com
Excellentblinklist
ExcellentBlogdigger
ExcellentBlogger
ExcellentBlogTalkRadio
Excellentbubble.us
ExcellentCafemom
ExcellentCampusbug
ExcellentCiteULike
ExcellentCommunityWalk
ExcellentCoverItLive
Excellentdelicious
Excellentdigg
Excellentdiigo
ExcellentDrupal
ExcellentEasy Chirp formerly named "Accessible Twitter"
ExcellentEdublogs
ExcellenteHow
ExcellentEpernicus
Excellenteprints 3.3.10
Excellentepub reader firefox add on
ExcellentESLvideo
ExcellentFacebook
ExcellentFlektor
ExcellentFlickr Tell a Story in 5 Frames
ExcellentFlicktion
ExcellentFotopages
Excellentfrappr
ExcellentFriends Reunited
ExcellentGlogster
ExcellentGoogle Maps
ExcellentGoogle Reader
ExcellentGoogle Sites
ExcellentGrazr
ExcellentHot Potatoes
ExcellentIMDb
ExcellentInstructables
ExcellentJayCut
ExcellentJooce
ExcellentKindle Cloud Reader
ExcellentLast.fm
ExcellentLinoit
ExcellentMindmeister
ExcellentMindomo
ExcellentMobile Facebook
ExcellentmyExperiment
ExcellentmynoteIT
ExcellentMyPodcast.com
ExcellentNetcipia
ExcellentNew 1000 ad
ExcellentNing
ExcellentNotefish
ExcellentOur Wishing Well
ExcellentOverstream
ExcellentPicBoard
ExcellentRemember The Milk
ExcellentSclipo
ExcellentScribd
ExcellentShelfari
ExcellentStumbleUpon
ExcellentTalkr
ExcellentTeacherTube
ExcellentTwitter
ExcellentType with Me
ExcellentVeoTag
ExcellentVideoJug
ExcellentViewbook
ExcellentVoiceThread
ExcellentVox
ExcellentVuvox
ExcellentWetpaint Wiki
ExcellentWindows Live SkyDrive
ExcellentWriteboard
ExcellentXtimeline
ExcellentYouTube
ExcellentZoho Show
Good21Classes
GoodATutor
Goodb2evolution
GoodBlabberize
GoodBookr
GoodBubblePLY
GoodBubbleShare
GoodBubblr
GoodConnotea
GoodDiigo WebSlides
GoodDisabled United Website
GoodDoodle
GoodDropbox
GoodEmpressr
GoodFastladder
GoodFlickr
GoodFriendFeed
GoodGliffy
GoodGoogle Calendar
GoodGoogle Docs (Office suite)
GoodGoogle Presenter
GoodGoogle Wave
GoodiSurvey
GoodLinkedIn
GoodMapwing
GoodMyPlick
GoodNotecentric
GoodObsidian Portal
GoodPhotobucket
GoodPlurk
Goodpopurls
GoodScreencast.com
GoodShowbeyond
GoodSlideShare
GoodTeambox
GoodTechnorati
GoodTiddlywiki
Goodtumblr
GoodWayfaring
GoodWikipedia / Mediawiki
GoodWiZiQ
GoodWordPress
GoodYahoo Answers
GoodYoYo Games
GoodZentation
Fairbabycenter.com
FairCloudWorks
FairComiqs
FairDimdim
FairDisability Community Website
FairflickrSLiDR
FairMotionbox
FairParenting
FairPrezi
PoorChartle.net
PoorCLEAR RIA
PoorLiveJournal
PoorPBworks (PBwiki)
PoorTokbox
PoorxFRUITS